Property Shield Logo

Case Study

3 Hours Back Every Week: How Renter's Place Uses Property Shield to Stop Rental Scams

November 12, 2026

~3 hours

saved per week on tracking, reporting, and managing fraudulent listings

1 to 2

fraud-related calls per month, all resolved right away

At a Glance

  • ~3 hours saved per week on tracking, reporting, and managing fraudulent listings
  • 1 to 2 fraud-related calls per month, all resolved right away

Objective

Show how a property management company can stop scammers from impersonating its brand and reclaim team time by replacing manual listing monitoring with Property Shield.

Background

Renter's Place is a property management and asset management company based in Tulsa, Oklahoma, serving property owners and investors.

The Problem

Scammers were posing as Renter's Place representatives and advertising the company's homes through fake listings, leading to multiple incidents per month of prospective applicants being scammed. The team was manually monitoring Craigslist and Facebook Marketplace, but fraudulent listings were hard to track down, and when they were removed, they reappeared quickly.

The Solution

Renter's Place added Property Shield to monitor all of its active listings, making sure prospects reach the company directly instead of responding to scam listings they find online.

Implementation

Onboarding was led by Allysa, who ran a formal software training with the whole team and stayed responsive to follow-up questions. Setup was simple, and the platform fit easily into the leasing team's routine: instead of hunting for scams across marketplaces, the team checks the dashboard a few times a week and acts only on items marked "action needed." Features like the fraud map, direct links to fraudulent listings, and an organized dashboard keep everything in one place.

Results

  • ~3 hours saved per week previously spent tracking down and reporting fraudulent listings and helping affected prospects
  • Fewer calls from prospects about fraudulent listings, with the remaining 1 to 2 per month resolved right away
  • Prospects routed back into the normal leasing process, so the team can locate residents and move them through standard procedures
  • A stronger promise to owners: constant monitoring of vacant properties to protect their assets and investments

Methodology & Assumptions

  • Time savings reflect the team's estimate of weekly hours previously spent on fraud tracking, reporting, and prospect support
  • Incident figures are based on the team's reported monthly volume of fraud-related cases before and after implementing Property Shield
  • No specific dollar savings were calculated; financial impact reflects recovered staff time

Analysis & Takeaway

For a property manager, a scam listing isn't just a lost lead: it's a direct hit to brand trust. By centralizing detection and surfacing only what needs action, Property Shield let Renter's Place stop playing whack-a-mole with relisted scams and position fraud protection as added value for the owners it serves.

Testimonial

"I would recommend Property Shield to anyone looking to have an extra layer of protection on their rental property. This service ensures that you will have a dedicated team assisting you with monitoring your property during the vacancy period. The cost of the service is VERY reasonable for what you are getting included."

  • Renter's Place team

Want Similar Results for Your Portfolio? Reach Out to Property Shield Today. Learn how you can save thousands with our industry-trusted solution against scam and fraud.

Book a 30-min demo

Case Studies

Want Similar Results for Your Portfolio? Reach Out to Property Shield Today

Explore how you can save thousands with our industry-trusted solution against scam and fraud.